Go Back
marshmallows over melted chocolate in a cast iron skillet with a side of graham crackers
Print Recipe
3.15 from 7 votes

NATURALLY-SWEETENED MARSHMALLOWS RECIPE

One of the best things of summer is campfires with homemade naturally-sweetened marshmallows. This simple recipe is healthy and nourishing!
Author: Amy | Our Amyable Farmhouse

Equipment

  • Electric mixer with whisk attachment—this is similar to the one I use. I have an old, gifted KitchenAid Heavy Duty K5SS model. Works like a champ! Man cub added some gear grease to it when it started making a weird sound and seized up after about 5 years of my use, and made it work like new again. He’s amazing, he’s my hero!
  • 9×13″ glass dish, or this pretty dish (I like pretty things)

Ingredients

  • 1/3 cup cool water
  • 1/3 cup water just off the boil
  • 4 TBS grass-fed gelatin
  • 1 cup maple syrup honey, or sweetener of choice (I’ve also used 2/3 cup monk fruit with great results)
  • Generous pinch of quality mineral salt I use himalayan salt
  • 1/2 tsp real vanilla learn how I make my own

Instructions

  • To the bowl of your mixer, add 1/3 cup water and sprinkle the gelatin over to bloom.
  • To the bloomed gelatin (basically just cool water soaked up by the gelatin) add the off the boil water to dissolve the gelatin. Stir until all dissolved.
  • Turn mixer on lowest setting and slowly add sweetener of choice. Add remaining ingredients.
  • Turn mixer up to high and beat until soft peaks form. The longer (stiffer) you beat, the more rustic your marshmallows will look. Not a bad thing. Just a little more difficult to spread into pan for us type-A people. Uh hem.
  • Pour into a greased 9×13″ pan and refrigerate until set, about an hour.
  • Flip out marshmallow cake onto cutting board and slice up to desired size.
  • Store in airtight container in fridge or freezer.
  • Toss in powdered sugar or arrowroot starch to keep from sticking if desired.
  • To roast, leave out on cookie racks for several days to create a dry “shell” about them. They toast over campfires BEAUTIFULLY!